Book Reviews

Book Cover

Book Cover - Demolishing the Myth: The Tank Battle of Prokhorovka, Kursk, July 1943 ~ An Operational Narrative

Demolishing the Myth:
The Tank Battle of
Prokhorovka, Kursk, July 1943: An Operational Narrative

by Valeriy Zamulin

Solihull, UK: Helion and Company Ltd., 2011
ISBN: 978 1 906033 89 7
630 pages, $69.96 (hc)

Reviewed by Chris Buckham

Print PDF

For more information on accessing this file, please visit our help page.

With the fall of the Soviet Union in 1989, many documents and unit records of Soviet operations during the Second World War became available to scholars. Valeriy Zamulin has taken advantage of this opportunity to draft an outstanding operational history of the Battle of Prokhorovka. Fought on the Southern Front of the Kursk conflict between 2 and 17 July, 1943, this battle represented the zenith of German offensive capability on the Eastern Front. From this point on, German efforts were defensive in nature, while Russian operations transitioned onto the offensive full-time.

Of note in Zamulin’s book is that it is written from the perspective of the Soviet forces. He has taken advantage of numerous first-hand accounts, ranging in perspective from junior soldiers to Front Commanders, and they provide context and depth to the narrative. While the scope of his study is relatively narrow (the Battle of Prokhorovka within the larger Kursk conflict); the breadth of his operational narrative is such that it provides a clear sense of the challenges faced by the Russian commanders controlling the fast-moving and fluid conflict.

Zamulin’s approach to the Russian command performance during the battle is balanced and objective. His use of daily logs, orders, situational reports, and first-hand recollections highlight some of the strengths and weaknesses of Russian command and control. Specifically, the tendency of the Russians to be extremely stratified in their decision making is repeatedly identified. Interestingly, the pressure exerted upon senior commanders to perform effectively was compounded by the implied (and real) threat of consequences, should they fail. This expectation resulted in ‘micro-management,’ and a fear of error that permeated throughout the command structure.  Zamulin, by example, refers to a scenario wherein Stalin himself directed that, just prior to the initiation of the Soviet counterattack on 12 July 1943, the senior Front Commanders and their senior staffs spread themselves between each of their individual regional headquarters. Thus, the Front Commander, his Chief of Staff, and other key commanders were physically separated while trying to coordinate a multi-army, combined arms battle.

One of the real strengths of this book is the ability of the author to expose the reader to both the interdependent role under which the various arms operated, and the individual challenges and success that each combat arm faced. This battle revealed a growing confidence in the Russian military leadership in their abilities and equipment. Many errors were committed and these are discussed within the larger narrative of the battle, and weaknesses were highlighted in the senior leadership’s ability/experience level to coordinate effective counterattacks using combined arms assaults. Nevertheless, it is evident from the overall performance of the Russian command and soldiers that morale and competency had improved dramatically.

What I particularly enjoyed about Zamulin’s book is the way that he presents his evaluation of the battle. Thus, while he sets his third-person narrative at the operational level, in order to provide context and depth, he seamlessly transitions to the tactical level and first-person dialogue. This provides the reader with a much greater appreciation of what was going on within the ‘heads’ of the individual commanders and soldiers. Additionally, while this book is primarily a narrative dealing with the Russian experience, he does make a concerted effort to include the German perspective, which adds further context and flavour.

Another strength is Zamulin’s chronological presentation of Prokhorovka. Therefore, despite the complexity of the battle, the reader is easily able to follow as the battle unfolds from the German offensive conducted from 2 to 12 July, to the transition to the Russian counter- offensive  running from 12 to 17 July. Zamulin has obviously researched the units involved in great depth. Included within the narratives (in chart format) are breakdowns of unit strengths by vehicle type and personnel, unit replacement rates, and overall loss rates for both the German and Russian combatants.

Zamulin concludes his narrative by addressing the commonly-held beliefs of historians surrounding the Battle of Prokhorovka. Using primary source documentation only recently made available to historians, he refutes, for example, the idea that Prokhorovka involved the largest concentration of armour involved in a single combat operation on the Eastern Front. Additionally, he summarizes very succinctly the strengths and weaknesses of the Russian commanders, from an experience viewpoint,as well as from a doctrinal and quality of equipment perspective.

Rounding off his book is a comprehensive listing of all of the units from both sides involved in the battle. He also provides an in-depth bibliography of his primary and secondary sources. One observation that I would make involves the concentration of the maps into one section of the book. While this is a very small point that in no way takes away from the narrative, strategic placement elsewhere would have made tracking the battle easier for the casual reader.

This is an outstanding historical analysis of a ‘battle within a battle.’ Valeriy Zamulin’s work represents, for both the military professional and the casual military historian, a work of profound depth and scope. There is something here for any branch of the combat arms professions and for operators in a joint environment. The cost in lives and materiel was horrific, but the Russians learned many lessons from their experiences during the Battle of Prokhorovka, and they did not waste time in applying those lessons downstream.

Major Chris Buckham, CD, BA, MA, a Logistics Officer in the Royal Canadian Air Force. is presently employed as an ILOC Officer with the multinational branch of EUCOM J4 in Stuttgart, Germany.